News: Untamed Heart: Wahoo is more popular than Yahoo!

Main Menu

Is releasing a Klonoa fangame currently illegal under Bandai Namco's TOS

Started by PhantomShiba, April 12, 2023, 11:45:05 PM

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

PhantomShiba

I am working on a Klonoa Fangame under the title Klonoa: Whispers from the Wind. I looked through Bandai Namco's site and I am still kinda unsure, would releasing a Klonoa fangame be illegal due to copyright infringement, IP, and other forms of licensing. I don't wanna go through more legal stuff of Namco's website so I'm just asking here and I didn't really know where else to post this.  :embarassed: It seems like Namco isn't too supportive of fangames but I wanna double check. If it isn't legal I'll see if I could contact them but it's unlikely they'd respond  x_x  :unsure: Thank you!  ;)
-PHANTOM SHIBA (Moxie)-
(Actual age: 15 - I made a mistake on my profile :p)

ThatGuy70 (Mikey)

Okay, so as a rule of thumb, as of now, any and all fanwork that uses existing IP is illegal. But there's others who were working on Klonoa fan games and I don't think they ever encountered any trouble. And there's a whole slew of Klonoa fan music that was never touched by Namco either, so you should be fine. Companies can be lax about properties

rapappa the pepper

I think you can release a fan game, if you don't profit out of it at all. I mean i have the guts to start working on a fan game... Uhhh... Also this ain't Nintendo y'know... And, Namco even at one point hosted a thing with fan games!
Is this a forum they forgot, or has the forum forgot them?
Hello, i'm i guess a general artist, 3D modeller, 2D traditional illustrator, and some times make music. You can know more about me at my Neo Cities: https://rapthepep.neocities.org/

If you want me to work on a project of yours, please contact me!

ThatGuy70 (Mikey)

Oh my god Nintendo WHAT!? Nintendo supporting fanwork literally sounds like blasphemy

But it wouldn't hurt if they did it more often :)

SummerShores

Quote from: ThatGuy70 (Mikey) on April 13, 2023, 02:35:30 AM
Okay, so as a rule of thumb, as of now, any and all fanwork that uses existing IP is illegal. But there's others who were working on Klonoa fan games and I don't think they ever encountered any trouble. And there's a whole slew of Klonoa fan music that was never touched by Namco either, so you should be fine. Companies can be lax about properties

This is more or less how I see the situation - most companies don't seem to really care about fangames unless they're for-profit. (There have been exceptions, of course, but in Klonoa's case Namco isn't likely to pursue legal action.)

PhantomShiba

Quote from: SummerShores on April 14, 2023, 01:18:22 AM
This is more or less how I see the situation - most companies don't seem to really care about fangames unless they're for-profit. (There have been exceptions, of course, but in Klonoa's case Namco isn't likely to pursue legal action.)
It's nice to see companies be less cut-throat with stuff like this. Last I checked Nintendo has been a lil less strict with their music takedowns and with taking down fan-games and projects. I've been seeing this in other companies too and it's quite refreshing to see  :D
-PHANTOM SHIBA (Moxie)-
(Actual age: 15 - I made a mistake on my profile :p)

RAYDEN

I've once been told by a software professor to NEVER develop a fangame or a related unauthorized project. Still, as long as it's not something you intend to monetize in any way, I think you should be in an OK moral standing. Plus it is still a pretty good learning experience from a gamedev perspective.
Drink up, me 'earties, yo ho